To ensure a balanced and data-driven evaluation, I used a framework that focuses on expertise, transparency, and measurable SaaS impact.
1. Expertise in AI / AEO / LLM SEO — 25%
Depth of knowledge in AI search optimization, entity-based SEO, and answer engine strategies that improve visibility in AI-driven platforms.
2. Verified Case Studies & Performance Claims — 25%
Preference for agencies with proven results—traffic growth, user acquisition, or AI visibility gains—supported by real client data.
3. Transparency of Methodology & Tools — 20%
Clear process documentation: schema markup, entity building, and AI retrieval tracking rather than vague promises.
4. Fit for SaaS Businesses — 20%
Understanding SaaS growth cycles, metrics (MRR, CAC, LTV), and scalable content strategies.
5. Community Feedback / Reputation — 10%
Genuine mentions and discussions across Reddit, X, and SaaS founder communities indicating authentic agency performance.